41363
wp-singular,portfolio_page-template-default,single,single-portfolio_page,postid-41363,wp-theme-stockholm,stockholm-core-2.4,qodef-qi--no-touch,qi-addons-for-elementor-1.11.2,select-theme-ver-9.5,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,qode_menu_,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-9.1,vc_responsive,elementor-default,elementor-kit-38031
Title Image

Sweat and Subjectivity Copyright Impulses
Danny Friedmann
Article

Sweat and Subjectivity Copyright Impulses
Danny Friedmann
Article

  The full text of this Article may be found here.

36 Fordham Intell. Prop. Media & Ent. L.J. 170 (2025).

Article by Danny Friedmann*

ABSTRACT

[G]enerative artificial intelligence (gAI) is generating vast volumes of content, including visual art with minimal human effort that competes directly with visual artists and threatens to dilute human culture in the process. In response, courts and copyright offices are quietly reintroducing two doctrines long considered incompatible with modern copyright: sweat of the brow, which rewards labor over originality, and aesthetic discrimination, which risks conditioning protection on perceived merit.

This article is the first to demonstrate how legal authorities are reintroducing these discredited doctrines under the guise of regulating AI-assisted outputs, thereby eroding the set of copyright doctrines accepted by most jurisdictions, which this author calls copyright doctrinal acquis. This article bridges the philosophical foundations of copyright law, Lockean labor theory, Kantian autonomy, and Hegelian personality theory with questions raised by gAI and brain-computer interface convergence. It synthesizes case law from the U.S., China, and Europe to demonstrate a converging yet incoherent response to AI-generated products that threatens to resurrect rejected doctrines under new terminology.

This Article reframes the copyright eligibility threshold in the age of gAI not around input quantity or output quality, but around demonstrable freedom of choice and human expressive originality.

It proposes four concrete, unprecedented policy reforms to recalibrate copyright law in light of gAI: (1) a freedom of choice requirement, (2) evidentiary support, (3) streamlined formalities, and (4) tiered registration fees.


*Associate Professor of Law, Dr., Peking University School of Transnational Law, Shenzhen, China. Contact: [email protected]. I would like to thank the participants of the “XX IDP Conference on Neurotechnology and AI: Legal Frontiers and Governance,” at Universitat Oberta de Catalunya, Barcelona, July 3, 2025. I also would like to thank the participants of the “APCA 2024 Conference: The Crossvergence of Asian Copyright Standards?” at City University of Hong Kong, on Nov. 18-19, 2024. I also thank Professors Mark Feldman, Phil McConnaughay, Ray Campbell, Gilad Abiri, Andrew Kerr, Emanuel Towfigh, Rostam Neuwirth, Chen Jun, and Mathijs van Basten Batenburg for discussing parts of an earlier version of the article.